I get what you’re saying, but the nature of scouting in general today is that you nit pick every single possible tiny flaw. No one has clean scout reports ever any more.
On the nfls draft scout page they use a 3-8 grading system. 8 is perfect 5.5 is priority free agent.
The vast majority of prospects who play in the cfl and nfl as rookies every year fall between a 5.1 and a 6.5, the big differentiator these days between nfl talent and cfl talent, is size and athleticism. We get a few guys league wide like Adam’s each yeah, every nfl team gets one or two like that.
Now the difference between elite nfl players and average nfl starters is a big gap in terms of the chess game and polish.
Tyreek hill was a 5.1. Marvin Harrison jr, the 4th overall pick, was a 6.83. Qb Bryce young, the first overall pick, was a 6.82. At the back end of the 3rd round they are drafting guys who are high 5 range. Dalton schoen was a 5.19. Chris smith was a 5.95.
These were their flaws.
Weaknesses
Room for improvement with release against press.
Allowed grabby coverage too much leeway in disrupting his routes.
Needs better route efficiency without as much stutter-stepping.
Might not have enough blow-by speed to consistently outrun NFL corners.
Had uncharacteristic drops in 2023
Weaknesses
Weighed in at 204 pounds at the NFL Scouting Combine; since 2003, no QB who weighed fewer than 207 pounds at the combine has been drafted in Round 1.
Durability will be a concern due to slight frame.
Has a tendency to run receivers up against the boundary.
Leaves his lower half behind on drive throws at times.
Needs to prove he can find reads quickly and stay on schedule.
Deep throws come out flat and lose energy late.
Doesn’t run as often as he could to counter the rush and pick up first downs.