I’ll give it to you straight up. I have taught gr. 12 Law for about a dozen years, and I have several police officer friends, they come to my class as guest speakers. Yes, about 90% of the criminals they deal are repeat offenders. Yes, the correctional system has a high number of Aboriginal inmates.
But to say our crime rate would be lower if we didn’t have any Aboriginals? The issues with Aboriginals are not only the fault of Aboriginals, not by a long shot.
1. The longest running human rights abuse in recorded world history is residential schools in Canada. From New France in 1600s until the last one closed in 1996.
2. If you want to learn more about residential schools for Aboriginals, go to the Canadian Encyclopedia and search residential schools. I would also recommend reading ‘Clearing the Plains’ by James Daschuck.
3. Even just a cursory glance at the current situation, shows a situation that will naturally create a higher crime rate. All of it created by government legislation, namely, The Indian Act.
a) Funding per person that is below welfare levels, with local politics worsening the situation, due to unfair distribution.
b) Education funded at a rate of $4300 per students, when the public education system is spending $10 000 per student.
c) Teaching staff that will be snapped up by school divisions in large urban centres, as soon as they have gained experience and proven to be effective.
I could go on, but considering all of the above, it is clear that the high Aboriginal crime rate is a shared responsibility.
I also want to add one final point - it’s not that Australia and New Zealand don’t have Aboriginals - they actually have world renowned English as a second language education programs for their Aboriginal students.