Lots going on. As mentioned earlier, The Stove has re-signed in BC...also:
 

 and 

 

 

 

Edited November 23, 20232 yr by Noeller

Andy Fantuz does girl push-ups

Farhan, who was convinced the CFL couldn't survive without the XFL and tried to convince everyone else of this, is going into the HOF. The bar is so tremendously low for entry, it kind of makes it worthless. 

12 minutes ago, JCon said:

Farhan, who was convinced the CFL couldn't survive without the XFL and tried to convince everyone else of this, is going into the HOF. The bar is so tremendously low for entry, it kind of makes it worthless. 

The HOF has a category for slobbering over the BC Lions?

14 minutes ago, rebusrankin said:

The HOF has a category for slobbering over the BC Lions?

They do now I guess

Geez, might as well throw Arash in there too

1 hour ago, 17to85 said:

Andy Fantuz does girl push-ups

Andy Fantuz eats corn the long way 

51 minutes ago, rebusrankin said:

The HOF has a category for slobbering over the BC Lions?

It's telling that I didn't even have to read the quote in your post to know exactly who you are talking about.

Edited May 4, 20241 yr by Wanna-B-Fanboy

Chad Owens & Weston Dressler get into the CFHOF but Robert Drummond & Craig Ellis don't. No politics there.

Drummond was a dominant running back for the Baltimore Stallions, Argos & Lions. He rushed for nearly 6,706 yards & scored 66 touchdowns rushing. Drummond caught another 391 passes for 4,033 yards & 18 touchdowns. He had 10,790 all purpose yards & scored 78 touchdowns. Drummond was the 2000 CFL MOP. & had numerous all star awards. While Ellis had 12,828 all purpose yards, scored 88 touchdowns. Ellis was 2 time CFL West Division & All Canadian as well. 

Looks like Stove has retired. ☹️

https://3downnation.com/2024/05/02/making-room-b-c-lions-release-veteran-canadian-dl-david-menard-transfer-dt-steven-richardson-to-retired-list/

Dave Dickenson was the 2000 CFL MOP.

Drummond just didn't have the longevity.  But he won 4 Grey Cups in his short career.

IMO the CFL HOF is already way too broad.  Like Marvin Coleman?  Calgary Stampeders Hall of Fame sure...league Hall of Fame...don't think so.

Should be guys that were the absolute best player at their position or in that conversation for a significant period of time.

1 hour ago, bigg jay said:

Looks like Stove has retired. ☹️

https://3downnation.com/2024/05/02/making-room-b-c-lions-release-veteran-canadian-dl-david-menard-transfer-dt-steven-richardson-to-retired-list/

I once saw Stove eat a whole live chicken. That two-ton man-mountain could palm a medicine ball.

Edited May 4, 20241 yr by kelownabomberfan

2 hours ago, JuranBoldenRules said:

Dave Dickenson was the 2000 CFL MOP.

Drummond just didn't have the longevity.  But he won 4 Grey Cups in his short career.

IMO the CFL HOF is already way too broad.  Like Marvin Coleman?  Calgary Stampeders Hall of Fame sure...league Hall of Fame...don't think so.

Should be guys that were the absolute best player at their position or in that conversation for a significant period of time.

wasnt Coleman like second highest career defensive tds or some thing? 
 6 time divisional all star 3 time league all star at corner plus 3 time divisional all star as a kr. 28 picks 6 returned for tds plus 7 kr tds. Had good longevity as a kr and cb but certainly wasn’t the same guy here that he was in his prime. But he was still a good player. 
hard to say and db is harder to pick hofers at imo. He was a better db imo than Drummond a rb for their careers. 

Farhan in the HOF.... Incredible. 

6 hours ago, bigg jay said:

Looks like Stove has retired. ☹️

https://3downnation.com/2024/05/02/making-room-b-c-lions-release-veteran-canadian-dl-david-menard-transfer-dt-steven-richardson-to-retired-list/

He's retired around 3 times now. 

Eight seasons isn't longevity? Man JBR, that's cutting it really thin as a reason for keeping Drummond out of the CFHOF saying he lacked longevity when the average football career isn't even 4 years.

How many years did Dressler & Goldsmith play?? Goldsmith played ten seasons from 1981-90 & Dressler played 11 seasons from 2008-18 but missed 25 games with injuries from 2014-18. So, he missed a season & a half which is the equivalent of 9 1/2 seasons & not 11. 

You look at the stats & championships. It's there for all to see. Drummond had 10,790 all purpose yards. Broken down that's 6,706 yds rushing with 60 TDs & 4,033 yards receiving with 18 TDs. He had another 51 yards returning kicks for zero touchdowns. That's 78 total touchdowns along with 4 Grey Cup rings. Just incredible stats. I remember Drummond as a monster. If he didn't kill teams as a runner then he killed them as a receiver. He dominated games as a player. If there was a knock on Drummond, he played very little Special Teams. 

Dickenson may have won the CFL's MOP award in 2000 but Drummond won the 2000 Grey Cup MOP Award. , 

Edited May 4, 20241 yr by SpeedFlex27

3 hours ago, SpeedFlex27 said:

He's retired around 3 times now. 

He was on the injured list all of the 2022 season, released before the 2023 season and now moved to the retired list so it seemsit might be a bit different than past situations.  

If he was still trying to make a comeback, they could have used one of the first two methods.

The Stove was unplugged because of torn achillies injuries....He was never coming back.....

11 hours ago, SpeedFlex27 said:

Eight seasons isn't longevity? Man JBR, that's cutting it really thin as a reason for keeping Drummond out of the CFHOF saying he lacked longevity when the average football career isn't even 4 years.

How many years did Dressler & Goldsmith play?? Goldsmith played ten seasons from 1981-90 & Dressler played 11 seasons from 2008-18 but missed 25 games with injuries from 2014-18. So, he missed a season & a half which is the equivalent of 9 1/2 seasons & not 11. 

You look at the stats & championships. It's there for all to see. Drummond had 10,790 all purpose yards. Broken down that's 6,706 yds rushing with 60 TDs & 4,033 yards receiving with 18 TDs. He had another 51 yards returning kicks for zero touchdowns. That's 78 total touchdowns along with 4 Grey Cup rings. Just incredible stats. I remember Drummond as a monster. If he didn't kill teams as a runner then he killed them as a receiver. He dominated games as a player. If there was a knock on Drummond, he played very little Special Teams. 

Dickenson may have won the CFL's MOP award in 2000 but Drummond won the 2000 Grey Cup MOP Award. , 

Drummond played parts of 8 seasons and was a primary back for the Argos in 2 seasons, Lions in 1.  Otherwise shared the backfield.

Not a CFL HOFer.

I dislike farhan with a passion but he has done lots for football on the left coast. 
 

CFL hall of fame worthy? No. Canadian football hall of fame worthy? Probably 

 

Do we even have both. 

BC Football HOF? Maybe. And that's it. Just being part of the laziest broadcasters does not earn you a CFL HOF induction. 

I think it's more about his work coaching minor football in BC, but still... In terms of media, I'd have Tait and Irving in there before him. Just because you're regional and not national shouldn't have any bearing.

2 hours ago, Noeller said:

I think it's more about his work coaching minor football in BC, but still... In terms of media, I'd have Tait and Irving in there before him. Just because you're regional and not national shouldn't have any bearing.

They are.

https://cfhof.ca/hof-reporters/

 

9 hours ago, WinnipegGordo said:

They are.

https://cfhof.ca/hof-reporters/

 

Ahhhh yes the reporters wing.... I'd forgotten all about that. 

On 2024-05-04 at 10:08 AM, Stickem said:

The Stove was unplugged because of torn achillies injuries....He was never coming back.....

Even if he came back, it would’ve been one of the most miraculous recoveries ever if we was the same guy again. 

No interest in Menard. I’d rather we go three American rotation off the edges and rotate Canadians in the one DT spot, with Hubert maybe filling an emergency role as a guy who could take a snap or two anywhere. 
 

Makonzo is a guy I’d be interested in, pending knowledge of why he was released in Edmonton. If he just got lost in the wash there after his injury, bring him in. If it was anything personality related, no thanks.

There's so few reporters on the CFL beat it won't be long until JC Abbott and John Hodge are in the HOF.