17to85 Posted Wednesday at 12:37 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 12:37 PM 9 hours ago, rebusrankin said: Milligan or Rourke, who is more overrated at this point? Now that is is tough question. Noeller 1
Booch Posted Wednesday at 01:21 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 01:21 PM 43 minutes ago, 17to85 said: Now that is is tough question. equally over rated...Rourke moreso I think tho as media just thinks that the Canadian angle is the bee's knee's
rebusrankin Posted Wednesday at 01:32 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 01:32 PM Next tough question, if Glen Suitor could only chose one, would it be Milligan or Rourke?
JuranBoldenRules Posted Wednesday at 01:44 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 01:44 PM 10 hours ago, rebusrankin said: Milligan or Rourke, who is more overrated at this point? Any Canadian player who is a twin. rebusrankin and Noeller 2
Booch Posted Wednesday at 01:47 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 01:47 PM 3 minutes ago, JuranBoldenRules said: Any Canadian player who is a twin. green gotch wearing bafoon...always leans Riders... Piggy 1 and wbbfan 2
wbbfan Posted Wednesday at 02:42 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 02:42 PM 11 hours ago, rebusrankin said: Milligan or Rourke, who is more overrated at this point? Rourke. Highest paid guy in the league by a lot. Milligan is solid on teams and a good db. He isn't the best but he's good. Db is a position you expect guys to excel at quickly to. At qb, the sophmore year is a hard hit and the way you really judge em is how they bounce back from that. Rourke is at that judging point now, but being paid like he's flutie 2.0. Coasting off his first half a year as a starter, which was 3 years ago is nuts. Rourke could be the 3rd or 4th best qb in the league this year, and that would still leave him wildly over rated and paid. I think he has as good a chance at having another brutal year as he does of being 3-4. rebusrankin, Bigblue204, HardCoreBlue and 1 other 4
Goalie Posted Wednesday at 03:23 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 03:23 PM (edited) Rourke. Dudes been getting glazed since before he started his first game. It’s not close. There is no way Rourke can ever live up to the hype. It’s impossible. BC would have to sell out every home game and the road teams they play would have to sell out all games Rourke comes to play for him to live up to the hype and BC would have to win more than 1 grey cup. At this point the goat cfl QB is collaros right now. No hype. Just a chip on his shoulder from a bogus suspension. That’s a good thing for Zach. A motivated pissed off Zach is best for the blue bombers. Edited Wednesday at 03:24 PM by Goalie wbbfan 1
Arnold_Palmer Posted Wednesday at 03:55 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 03:55 PM 1 hour ago, wbbfan said: Rourke. Highest paid guy in the league by a lot. Milligan is solid on teams and a good db. He isn't the best but he's good. Db is a position you expect guys to excel at quickly to. At qb, the sophmore year is a hard hit and the way you really judge em is how they bounce back from that. Rourke is at that judging point now, but being paid like he's flutie 2.0. Coasting off his first half a year as a starter, which was 3 years ago is nuts. Rourke could be the 3rd or 4th best qb in the league this year, and that would still leave him wildly over rated and paid. I think he has as good a chance at having another brutal year as he does of being 3-4. Rourkes 4 TDs, and 9 INT’s in 9 games is ugly! Especially considering how good BC’s receiving core was. Piggy 1, wbbfan, rebusrankin and 1 other 3 1
bluto Posted Wednesday at 03:57 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 03:57 PM 15 hours ago, wbbfan said: https://www.cfl.ca/2025/06/03/brady-oliveira-headlines-tsns-top-50-cfl-players-for-2025/ another brilliant list. The defending champions only have 4 of the top 50 players?
HardCoreBlue Posted Wednesday at 03:59 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 03:59 PM Just now, bluto said: The defending champions only have 4 of the top 50 players? I'll field that one. Argos suck? 17to85, johnzo, Super Duper Negatron and 1 other 2 1 1
Arnold_Palmer Posted Wednesday at 04:06 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:06 PM These lists are always terrible but I think it’s an absolute joke we don’t have a single DB in the top 50. Best secondary in football and I’d take Bonds, Nichols and possibly Holms on some of the DB’s who made the list. Bubba Zanetti and Noeller 2
3rdand1.5 Posted Wednesday at 04:14 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:14 PM Rourke is far and away the most overrated......Not only with media but with his over bloated salary rebusrankin and Goalie 2
Noeller Posted Wednesday at 04:27 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:27 PM Let's not take anything away from how overrated Milligan was last year. That was ******* absurd and based on almost nothing. rebusrankin, wbbfan and Bubba Zanetti 3
SpeedFlex27 Posted Wednesday at 04:37 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:37 PM Milligan had a season where everything went his way. To think he can duplicate what he did in 2024 or be even better is absurd. Bigblue204 1
rebusrankin Posted Wednesday at 04:37 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:37 PM (edited) Is Milligan Ed Gainey 2.0? Edited Wednesday at 04:38 PM by rebusrankin wbbfan 1
GCn20 Posted Wednesday at 04:52 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 04:52 PM 12 minutes ago, rebusrankin said: Is Milligan Ed Gainey 2.0? Definitely. Milligan was burned a ton in coverage all year but had a ton of interceptions from QBs throwing the ball right into his chest. He wasn't taking balls away in coverage like Ford did, he just happened to be standing in the right spot at the right time for a tip from the DL, or an errant throw. Stickem, rebusrankin, Bigblue204 and 2 others 5
Booch Posted Wednesday at 05:01 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 05:01 PM (edited) 9 minutes ago, GCn20 said: Definitely. Milligan was burned a ton in coverage all year but had a ton of interceptions from QBs throwing the ball right into his chest. He wasn't taking balls away in coverage like Ford did, he just happened to be standing in the right spot at the right time for a tip from the DL, or an errant throw. yeah he musta got some of the easiest INT's in a long time....dude several times was just standing in space and had ball hit him right in his chest...wasn't from extraordinary plays on the ball I used to rag on Holm but he busts up plays...tho I still dont like his physicality or tackling.....but if he had any hands at all he's have had Milligan int numbers but he has 2 stones for hands...but breaks up a lot...Nichols too....if he got the volume...he'd get the picks....The fact that fall past the brainiacs like the TSN gang is that Milligan gets targeted a lot....same with Houston....yeah they will get picks....but also burned a lot and give up lotsa plays in front of them Edited Wednesday at 05:02 PM by Booch rebusrankin, wbbfan and Noeller 3
greenrider55 Posted Wednesday at 05:32 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 05:32 PM Nathan Rourke actually got one vote for #1 on the top 50. As in best player in the league. What are the chances it was Farhan? wbbfan 1
Booch Posted Wednesday at 05:54 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 05:54 PM 21 minutes ago, greenrider55 said: Nathan Rourke actually got one vote for #1 on the top 50. As in best player in the league. What are the chances it was Farhan? I'd say 1900 % lol wbbfan 1
HardCoreBlue Posted Wednesday at 06:11 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 06:11 PM 36 minutes ago, greenrider55 said: Nathan Rourke actually got one vote for #1 on the top 50. As in best player in the league. What are the chances it was Farhan? Literally that person should lose their vote for being completely unserious. Noeller, wbbfan and Booch 2 1
Bigblue204 Posted Wednesday at 08:50 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 08:50 PM I'm so happy we're 28hrs away from CFL football again! HardCoreBlue, bluto, wbbfan and 3 others 2 4
bigg jay Posted Wednesday at 09:24 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 09:24 PM 4 hours ago, Noeller said: Let's not take anything away from how overrated Milligan was last year. That was ******* absurd and based on almost nothing. Just the colour of his jersey. Stick him on any other team and his name would have barely been mentioned last year. Noeller 1
wbbfan Posted Wednesday at 10:02 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 10:02 PM 1 hour ago, Bigblue204 said: I'm so happy we're 28hrs away from CFL football again! Qft. Good week of kick off games too. Brown vs ssk, tor vs mtl, and the wannabebombers vs the vaj stampers. Bigblue204, Noeller, bluto and 2 others 2 1 2
Super Duper Negatron Posted Wednesday at 10:14 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 10:14 PM 12 minutes ago, wbbfan said: Qft. Good week of kick off games too. Brown vs ssk, tor vs mtl, and the wannabebombers vs the vaj stampers. Man, a Vaj Stamp sounds like a painful tattoo.... HardCoreBlue, bigg jay, Bigblue204 and 4 others 7
Noeller Posted Wednesday at 10:32 PM Report Posted Wednesday at 10:32 PM (edited) 3 hours ago, Super Duper Negatron said: Man, a Vaj Stamp sounds like a painful tattoo.... I'm not sayin', I'm just sayin'.... I've known some ladies in my time........ Edited yesterday at 01:24 AM by Noeller wbbfan, bigg jay, Super Duper Negatron and 2 others 5
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now