Brandon

My original point was that Buck wasn't known as a tactician on the field.
Absolutely everything he displayed as a player would not indicate that he would be a great qb coach.

My original point was that Buck wasn't known as a tactician on the field.
Absolutely everything he displayed as a player would not indicate that he would be a great qb coach.

Until he slips up after a punt return touchdown by Dave Stala and he proceeds to go off about Sticky Stalas STD's in TD place!!

Why would we want buck as a qb coach???? Only because he has roots here that's a horrible reason to hire a guy.
Is it because of his stellar play with the Blue.....????
Is it his style which only worked when he would scramble and make a play on the fly with his legs???
Is it because he looked focus on the sidelines when he played and that he never appeared to be dazed or spaced out???
I see zero reason for him to be qb coach.
I'd rather they bring in a guy who with a good reputation for game planning and good with his x and o's and someone who could mentor.

Yes he is what he is... a guy who can score great on the power play and then stink it up on his own end....  the -15 or whatever he is at now is quite indicative as well as him being one of the top guys in the league with giveaways.  
 
Bogo isn't elite and definitely can't shoot for ****, but he at least can get the puck out of his own end and considering how crappy the team has been and he still somehow is a +6 really does show.  
 
 
Byfuglien isn't a scapegoat,  to me Pavelec also is vastly over rated....  Buff simply should be a forward because he's lazy as fack  and a liability on the D,   put him on the point for the power play but for the rest of the game put him in Thorburns place on the wing.
 
Claude Noel is in over his head,  not a horrible coach but definitely not a guy who can raise the bar on a team full of young guys.     

So no jokes about Pall being 5th overall pick only for them to instantly cut him and Montreal signing him?
Or is it only Mack picks that can be forever mocked?

Well as a fan when you see a guy like Foster get several chances to make first downs and simply drop the ball mean while once in a blue moon Etienne gets a ball his way and he makes the catch and gets some YAC it really makes it hard for us to really root for him to leave...

I wasn't aware of blaming everyone except yourself is considered class.....   while he didn't make a fool of himself like Reed did....  he also didn't show any emotion or really ever was honest with Bob or the fans in general.  

I wasn't aware of blaming everyone except yourself is considered class.....   while he didn't make a fool of himself like Reed did....  he also didn't show any emotion or really ever was honest with Bob or the fans in general.  

I wasn't aware of blaming everyone except yourself is considered class.....   while he didn't make a fool of himself like Reed did....  he also didn't show any emotion or really ever was honest with Bob or the fans in general.  

I wasn't aware of blaming everyone except yourself is considered class.....   while he didn't make a fool of himself like Reed did....  he also didn't show any emotion or really ever was honest with Bob or the fans in general.  

Not to mention much better job security and much more potential for career advancements....

No Etch and definitely no Marshall... god if we have Marshall we might as well forfeit every game against Ricky Ray since it's a given that he'll throw 40 straight complete passes and keep the offense on the field 75% of the game.   
 
As said before... why settle for guys who have been around the league and have never excelled above mediocrity.    I'd rather give it to someone with at least a chance to rise to the top. 

The same Hugh o Neill who struggled with routine kicks last year?
I'd rather Palardy

The same Hugh o Neill who struggled with routine kicks last year?
I'd rather Palardy

The same Hugh o Neill who struggled with routine kicks last year?
I'd rather Palardy

Like I already said .... If Boltus is back at training camp then that is a huge red flag

Like I already said .... If Boltus is back at training camp then that is a huge red flag

I agree with Doug Brown,  why bring anyone back associated with last years gong show of an offense.      
 
I think MB will have a near impossible challenge ahead of him because the fans are going to demand INSTANT results and I don't think we will have any sorts of patience with him.  I think it's a bad hire and one that could blow up in the clubs face.   
 
Now if Boltus comes back next season even for training camp then I officially will give up on next season and will patiently await for the next rebuild....

Wouldn't it be funny if Brink were to be signed by the Lions.....

Wouldn't it be funny if Brink were to be signed by the Lions.....

Berry has had success everywhere he has gone aside from Darian Durant crying liek a baby.    The guy is a good OC... not head coach material.    
 
Walters is saying the right stuff,   now if he can get a qb and actually address issues when they are presented (such as being weak in certain positions) then he will do much better then Mack.

Well in fairness he was on the right track,  didn't blow money on aging vets and tried to rebuild the canadian content and kept the draft picks.     
 
His downfall was keeping Buck around to long,  hiring the wrong OC's,  not fixing a broken o-line......  all critical errors.   

Well in fairness he was on the right track,  didn't blow money on aging vets and tried to rebuild the canadian content and kept the draft picks.     
 
His downfall was keeping Buck around to long,  hiring the wrong OC's,  not fixing a broken o-line......  all critical errors.   

If that was the case then why did O'shea sign here when he could of went elsewhere?