The thread for all things Star Wars from the box to the big screen and all things in between.

Obi-Wan, Chewy, R2D2, Leia, Spock, Rey, Kylo, etc.

 

 

Edited October 6, 20187 yr by FrostyWinnipeg

Looks like fan reviews are much more positive than critic reviews.  Which is sort of what I expected.  The critics like TLJ because they didn’t understand what fans want from Star Wars.  When I saw critics panning Skywalker I actually felt more positive about it going in. 

I saw it last night. 

Serious spoilers below, so please only read if you've seen it. There are a few things that I don't want to ruin.

Spoiler

Moved to spoiler thread. 

 

Edited December 20, 20196 yr by JCon

12 hours ago, The Unknown Poster said:

I think the non spoiler revenues I read are pretty spot on.  
 

it’s fast paced and doesn’t have much time to let things breath.  There is fan servicing but in my opinion, needed.   I feel like the film is a salvage project and makes TLJ look even worse in comparison.   
 

all the characters shine at points.  Fight scenes are cool.   They do answer a lot of questions though often without much explanation (and seems like lack of time was a factor).  
 

there are many plot contrivances.  Ie when they need a ship there is a ship. When they need help there is someone to do it.  But while that usually drives me nuts I kinda give JJ some slack because this is basically two films in one.  It’s fixing TLJ.  
 

Actors were all good.  Driver and Ridley especially.  And ofcourse Ian Mc.   There was genuinely some big emotional moments and some “yes so cool” moments.   A few things I’d change. But I’d go see it. If you liked TFA and hated TLJ go see it.  If you hated TFA you probably won’t like this one.  

The fight scenes deliver! 

JCON. There is a spoiler thread

2 minutes ago, tacklewasher said:

JCON. There is a spoiler thread

I didn't see it! 

I may go this weekend alone, or wait until my wife is able to go (she's a florist, so getting taking her out before Christmas doesn't work), so I like the non-spoiler reviews.

Hell. I'll go by myself and then go with her after.

So I’m a big Star Wars fan, but not 100% sure if I wanna see this one because the last Jedi may have ruined my love for it. Yes I think it was that bad. Is the new one worth seeing? 

3 hours ago, Tiny759 said:

So I’m a big Star Wars fan, but not 100% sure if I wanna see this one because the last Jedi may have ruined my love for it. Yes I think it was that bad. Is the new one worth seeing? 

Yes. Can't undo VIII but they try or just ignore it altogether. Go knowing that it's not perfect but it's perfectly good. 

43 minutes ago, JCon said:

Yes. Can't undo VIII but they try or just ignore it altogether. Go knowing that it's not perfect but it's perfectly good. 

Well that gives me some faith then

49 minutes ago, Tiny759 said:

Well that gives me some faith then

Its not like the trilogy bar was set high with Ep 6 and Ep 3.

1 hour ago, FrostyWinnipeg said:

Its not like the trilogy bar was set high with Ep 6 and Ep 3.

Well yes and no. They have flaws, but there was a story that it was telling. Ep 7,8 have been all over the place, terrible story line, cheesy line, bad acting. I could go on and on about how the new ones are terrible, but the originals and sequels at least were connected together and told a good story. These new ones seem like more of an extension of something that didn’t need to be extended.

That’s a good point.  And Skywalker seems connected to TFA but not at all connected to TLJ.  You almost don’t need to see it.   Even then it doesn’t really feel in the same narrative universe as the first two trilogies.  But again I blame that on TLJ.  

Spoiler-free hot take: for me, it wasn't as good as Rogue One, but it was easily the best of the modern Skywalker trilogy.

It knows who its audience is, and it serves them well.

Edited December 22, 20196 yr by johnzo

2 hours ago, johnzo said:

Spoiler-free hot take: for me, it wasn't as good as Rogue One, but it was easily the best of the modern Skywalker trilogy.

It knows who its audience is, and it serves them well.

Saw it today and will see it again. I had no intention of seeing TLJ twice, even on Netflix/Prime.

Only problem was I had a crappy sleep last night and actually missed part of it.

I really admire how some of you are  really into Star Wars & can dissect every film. This is when I feel old & even though I've seen every Star Wars since ANH in 1977 there is no way I can even enter into a discussion here. I feel like I'm on a stagecoach 150  years ago racing across the Nevada desert on my way to old San Francisco when it comes to this. 

10 hours ago, SpeedFlex27 said:

I really admire how some of you are  really into Star Wars & can dissect every film. This is when I feel old & even though I've seen every Star Wars since ANH in 1977 there is no way I can even enter into a discussion here. I feel like I'm on a stagecoach 150  years ago racing across the Nevada desert on my way to old San Francisco when it comes to this. 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stagecoach_West_(TV_series)

15 hours ago, SpeedFlex27 said:

I really admire how some of you are  really into Star Wars & can dissect every film. This is when I feel old & even though I've seen every Star Wars since ANH in 1977 there is no way I can even enter into a discussion here. I feel like I'm on a stagecoach 150  years ago racing across the Nevada desert on my way to old San Francisco when it comes to this. 

I'm always impressed here with the folks who can dissect football games at a level beyond "oh that touchdown was a good play!" which is where I'm at.  It's the exact same thing, just a different subject. 

Hope you enjoy the new film, Speedflex!

Edited December 22, 20196 yr by johnzo

16 hours ago, SpeedFlex27 said:

I really admire how some of you are  really into Star Wars & can dissect every film. This is when I feel old & even though I've seen every Star Wars since ANH in 1977 there is no way I can even enter into a discussion here. I feel like I'm on a stagecoach 150  years ago racing across the Nevada desert on my way to old San Francisco when it comes to this. 

Gotta remember, a lot of us saw star wars as kids, and we all know how kids obsess over things. 

Mandalorian is absolutely killing it .. the show has been really good.

1 hour ago, 17to85 said:

Gotta remember, a lot of us saw star wars as kids, and we all know how kids obsess over things. 

Yeah, I was 22 when ANH came out in 77. We never saw anything like it. Before Star Wars, spaceships were held up by strings & rocket engine exhaust looked like smoke from a candle.

It was the Ewoks. later Jar Jar Binks.  They turned me off Star Wars. I remember storming out of the theatre in 1981 muttering WTF I just saw. Everytime I see an Ewok, I just want to kill them. Slowly. Fricking teddy bears. Then in the 90's they introduced Jar Jar Binks.  Just an annoying character. I stopped following the storyline at the time. I just go now to be entertained.  

Edited December 22, 20196 yr by SpeedFlex27

1977 was a huge year for me.  I was four years old.  The previous xmas my brothers had gotten Led Zeppelin's IV, Kiss's Destroyer, and Rush's 2112, so the soundtrack was set. The following summer I saw Star Wars, the first film I ever saw in a movie theater -- I grew up extremely rural and seeing a movie in a theater was a huge deal for my family.

As Palpatine would say, my destiny was set.  I was gonna be a heavy metal sci fi kid until the day I died.

I’ll get flamed but I was always more into Star Trek than Star Wars.   Many of you might Consider the original trilogy a Christmas tradition as back in the days of limited channels they seemed to always play over the holidays.  That’s where I got to know them the most. 
 

 

32 minutes ago, The Unknown Poster said:

I’ll get flamed but I was always more into Star Trek than Star Wars.   Many of you might Consider the original trilogy a Christmas tradition as back in the days of limited channels they seemed to always play over the holidays.  That’s where I got to know them the most. 
 

 

I am as well. But Hollywood spoiled it with the Kelvin Universe. And now two Trek universes. Of which we have discussed.

 

21 hours ago, iHeart said:

 

Mando without the suit.