Not true in the least. Last year his completion percentage was under 60 percent, and he nearly threw 20 picks (18 to be exact). Yes he did finish second in yards passing with just over 4,200 yards, but when you consider that Drew Willy is just shy of 3,800 yards, coupled with the fact that he's missed a full game, plus halves against Edmonton and B.C., and that we still have a game to play, Willy would have thrown for more yards than Reilly last year.
Bottom line: Willy is exactly where he should be as a first year starter.
You're totally ignoring his 709 yards rushing, when the QB is a great rusher it's not nearly as essential that he has a percentage up the upper 60s. Also he did have a stretch in the middle of the year where his stats were pretty awesome. REILLY, M 2013-08-02 EDM HAM 32 21 65.6 311 40 1 3.1 0 0.0 107.7 REILLY, M 2013-08-18 EDM TOR 46 35 76.1 511 51 3 6.5 0 0.0 133.5 REILLY, M 2013-08-24 EDM SSK 29 19 65.5 303 41 3 10.3 2 6.9 106.0 REILLY, M 2013-09-02 EDM CGY 35 16 45.7 246 43 4 11.4 2 5.7 83.8 REILLY, M 2013-09-06 EDM CGY 26 16 61.5 194 27 0 0.0 0 0.0 84.5 REILLY, M 2013-09-14 EDM WPG 25 16 64.0 196 32 3 12.0 0 0.0 128.1 REILLY, M 2013-09-20 EDM WPG 46 31 67.4 418 51 1 2.2 0 0.0 103.4 REILLY, M 2013-09-28 EDM TOR 10 6 60.0 80 20 1 10.0 1 10.0 77.1
Again though, I was going by his stats, was just going by how many times he made say wow when I was watching him play.