Brandon

If you read my original post you would see my reasons.... mainly the lack of arm strength and his slow feet. Unless for some reason he was holding back I doubt that he's going to throw missiles in his next start.

What I don't get is those two guys make it seem like Goltz is missing guys by a mile.... maybe I have selective memory but most of Goltz incompletions that I remember were from drops and/or throwing the ball away instead of giving up the sack and losing yards.

No way Creehan is back next year with how pathetic this defense is looking this year..... Maybe he gets canned this season and Burke takes control over the defense for the rest of the season but I doubt it.... Who do you think we should bring in next year for the full rebuild to run our defense? I still say Mark Nelson would be a solid candidate... he was one of the few bright spots back in the Kelly dark years and his style of defense from what I remember was much less passive then the crap we have now with Creehan and the crap we had back with Marshall. With Nelson he made Odell Willis look like a superstar and same with the rest of the d-line... I think he could get a lot more out of the talent we have. Anyone have any other suggestions of coaches who might be available?

So one pass makes him a bad qb? What about 3 - 4 drops he had where the ball hit the receivers right in the hands or numbers?

Maybe the team should literally copy cat everything Calgary does lol. Copy some plays designed for Larry Taylor and use them with Woods.

Pierce is done as a starter... he may have value as a backup for this season. If he's not gone next year then we definitely need to raise hell at whoever is in charge by then....

I think you and ISO are way over reacting in Goltz's accuracy... it's like you guys make it seem like he was throwing lame ducks like Pierce or how Brink was last season where the ball would be 5 - 15 yards away from a wide open receiver. Goltz's accuracy was perfectly fine in his two starts, not a problem at all. His decisions at times were questionable, but being a young guy with barely any experience that is to be expected. You can teach a qb to read a defense... you can't teach a qb to throw a bullet. Ray is slow as crap, people make it seem like he has low arm strength which is a farce... he has arm strength but instead of bulleting it... he throws a perfect rainbow. Hall can throw a rainbow... but it's slow and easy for a defender to make a play on it.

Aaron Woods also deserved some kudos for the game last night.... But in regards to Hall , I don't mind them giving him another start just to see what he does. But my suggestion from the first post is purely based on the fact that I don't think he has the physical capabilities to succeed in this league. The lack of speed is ok , Calvillo survived in the league for the longest time with being a real slow poke... but the difference was that he could rifle a throw 25 yards down the field like a bullet and it would smack the receiver in the chest way before a defender could even make a play on it. You see guys like Burris and Durant able to run out of the pocket and just throw a heater down the field into a receivers hands.... with Hall (and Buck) you get a rainbow or a pass that looks like it's going in slow motion going down the field and hopefully into a wide open players hands. It's funny because I was joking with my wife when we were watching that when you see Burris throw a pass... the camera man has trouble keeping up with it because it goes down the field so fast... with Hall it was nice and slow and the camera can't even generate a blur because of how slow it's moving.... I know Arm strength isn't the end all be all (See Mike Bishop) , but you have to be able to throw some heat or even have enough arm strength to throw a decent pass to the sidelines.... Hall is not the answer unfortunately.... bring in someone more "athletic" like Durant/Burris....

I watched the game on my PVR today and Max Hall simply doesn't have the mobility or the arm strength to win in this league. I liked Max's composure and his ability to make reads, he does also throw a very nice soft pass. But yikes he is slow as a snail and he throws horribly when on the run and he was lucky that he didn't have around 4-5 interceptions. His bullets down the field were very dangerous and under thrown. It's to bad because he makes the right throws and when he can plant his foot he can throw very nicely placed Ricky ray like passes. I think Goltz however is way better suited for the cfl, his ability to buy time with his feet and the ability to throw darts makes him a way better option. I would surprisingly make Buck our backup and Hall the bench warmer. Hall simply can't play with this o line. Anyone agree?

The talent on the defense is there , its not like all these guys lost there skill over night.

I only watched the last few minutes but yikes how did Montreal give away that easy win... So many mistakes and lucky breaks they had and yet they still blew it. Lol at the players listing up popp after the fumble return and him being cocky only to lose it in the end. So will they Lynch neiswander since he didn't have great stats/?

Over/Under 200 yards passing for Max Hall?

When was the last time Buck was playing good and was healthy for 3 straight games? Glenn people complained and that was because we were spoiled from having Khari before him..... Buck has been TERRIBLE for the last 2 and half seasons....... 1 good game does not over ride his last 20 crap performances....

It's bizarre it's almost like the players are getting as injured as the guys in the UFC and WWE.... I wonder what they all have in common.... hmm

The unknown poster has gone missing...

I meant for next season, if we have ot pay him we might as well get a year out of him doing something...

Can we stay on topic here? I don't see why Sears or anyone really thinks this is a bad or even a surprising move. I'm actually shocked that Garrett made it out of training camp. Simpson is the better back, Ford is younger and healthier .... we really have no need for Garrett aside from being insurance incase Simpson gets hurt. Even so , rb's are dime a dozen and can be replaced in a heart beat. Good move to cut his salary and hopefully put it elsewhere where it's needed. If Simpson gets hurt, their will be a crap load of backs from NFL cuts and Garrett most likely won't be doing anything so they could always give him a call.

I'm simply saying this because Burke looks completely defeated and doesn't look like he wants to do this anymore and realizes that he's in over his head.

Goltz could learn something from him..

buck has had three years three oc's and has sucked with all.... Buck has had way to many chances. He can't throw accurately, with any velocity and he can't handle pressure... Three things coaches can't do to help him. No hope for Buck whatsoever

We've seen OC's demoted before in the league , would it be possible for the club to demote Burke to a DC next season and bring in a new head coach? He seems to want to escape the public pressure, clearly nobody is going to hire him as a HC anytime soon.... might as well pay him to do a job rather then paying him to sit on the couch? Would it be possible to give him the ultimatum of either being the DC or Quitting?

I know that Moranis was approached to do Ghostbusters 3... turned it down unfortunately.

I had friends who did this quite a bit, you will find better deals on more luxury vehicles. If you're looking at a lower to mid range type of vehicle it's really not worth it. You can however get fantastic deals on quads, bikes, boats and riding mowers....

Sign him and trade mainor?

I thought he quit acting after his wife died to take care of his family? It was either him or Dana Carvey that did that....