dmillerywg

I thought Knapp struggled against MTL as well so I would say he has played poorly the past 2 weeks.

I would rather see Knapp on the Bench, I haven't decided about Howard yet but to me Knapp is built like a TE and plays Tackle Like a TE Poorly 285 lbs is one hell of a TE.... Knapp is playing cuz of his athleticism... I think he can be a pretty effective player... perhaps he could afford to put a few of the pounds back on that he took off in the winter... My Concern is he is getting pushed back to the QB the past 2 games so he is too light and / or has bad technique. Even as bad as Boatman was last year at least he didn't get pushed around. I would rather see Javis Jones Play RT Please don't compare Knapp to Boatman. Knapp has had both good and bad games so far. Boatman was the same except for the part of the good games. Only comparing the results they have completely different styles but at least players had to go Around Boatman they are going Through Knapp... Knapp can run like no othe Lineman in the CFL but he has to be able to Protect the QB much better than he has been ! It would also be nice if Wiley was at practice during the week.

From the CFL Rulebook • When a ball carrier is on the ground and, in the judgment of the official, is not attempting to advance the ball, the official shall immediately declare the ball dead. So if a Player goes down on their own then are they not to be ruled Down ? Its the Officials call but if it was me and I saw a player going down on their own it suggests they are not trying to advance the ball ! I do agree that if no whistle the play is not dead but the argument the other side is making is the Offical should have ruled it dead because he gave himself up, as for AC a few years back he dove head first but lost the ball when he hit the ground ( so before the whisle )

I would rather see Knapp on the Bench, I haven't decided about Howard yet but to me Knapp is built like a TE and plays Tackle Like a TE Poorly 285 lbs is one hell of a TE.... Knapp is playing cuz of his athleticism... I think he can be a pretty effective player... perhaps he could afford to put a few of the pounds back on that he took off in the winter... My Concern is he is getting pushed back to the QB the past 2 games so he is too light and / or has bad technique. Even as bad as Boatman was last year at least he didn't get pushed around. I would rather see Javis Jones Play RT

I would rather see Knapp on the Bench, I haven't decided about Howard yet but to me Knapp is built like a TE and plays Tackle Like a TE Poorly

I doen't matter if its a QB or Not when a player gives themselves up they are DOWN. Its different if they stumble or have to go down to catch or pickup a ball if they willingly go down they are DOWN. Having given my 2 cents it was only 7 yards and it didn't effect the game at all.