Hello
Went down a rabbit hole one Sunday night and dug up the W/L numbers as starters for Collaros and Flutie (didn't have to go digging for Mitchell's with the milestone he just hit). Was sharing them with Noeller and 17to85 but thought maybe some of you might have interest. These are all current.
Win/Loss on a single team (minimum 50 Starts)
Flutie (Stamps) - 63 Starts - 50 W - 13 L. .794 winning percentage
Mitchell (Stamps) - 117 Starts - 90 W - 25 L - 2 T. .778 winning percentage
Collaros (Bombers 2019 - present) - 67 Starts - 51 W - 16 L. .761 winning percentage
All time Win/Loss
Flutie - 105 Starts - 78 W - 27 L. .743 winning percentage
Mitchell - 144 Starts - 101 W - 41 L - 2 T. .708 winning percentage
Collaros - 133 Starts - 85 W - 48 L. .639 winning percentage
A few observations.
I have given Bo 1 win for his 2 ties. Flutie's only real losing was to start his career in BC. And even that was only for 1 year. You can see his numbers with the Stamps, and by my count the 2 years he was an Argo, they went 15-3 both years. The only way to spin that Bo wins more than Flutie is to use the "fastest to 100 wins" when we know Flutie didn't play enough to get 100 wins. I was curious when I put this together if Bo's record was actually better than Flutie's. We can see its not, and isn't really that close. I guess when he first left Calgary, it was but he's dropped off since then. And Zack's run in Winnipeg... When he left Hamilton after 2017, he was 24-27 as a starter (even coming here he was only 34-32 as a starter after Sask), and since that time has somehow willed his way into the conversation here. Collaros would have been #1 on the team chart until 2024 happened. Almost half of all his losses as a bomber were in 2024. Mathematically he can't get to 100 wins in less than 143 (absolute best he can do now is 147), but I could see him passing Bo for all time wins or winning percentage all time. Flutie is probably untouchable, and I'm okay with that.